Insurance companies use specific tactics to minimize motorcycle accident claims in Missouri, including lowball settlement offers, requesting recorded statements, denying responsibility, and blaming the rider to reduce payouts under the state’s comparative fault system.
These strategies target your vulnerability after a crash and exploit legal loopholes to pay as little as possible.
Meanwhile, you’re dealing with treatment, bills, and missed work. They’re moving fast; you’re just trying to catch your breath. Knowing these tactics helps you avoid mistakes—like giving a broad medical release or agreeing to a statement before you’ve had proper guidance—and keeps your claim on solid ground.
How Insurers Minimize Missouri Motorcycle Claims
Insurance companies use specific tactics to reduce what they pay on motorcycle accident claims in Missouri. The goal is simple: pay you as little as possible, as quickly as possible.
Once the other party notifies their insurance company, things will move quickly. Without proper representation from our experienced St. Louis motorcycle accident attorneys, you may be forced to deal with the other party’s insurance company directly.
And if you are inexperienced, your case may be sunk before it has a chance of ever getting off the ground.
Lowball Settlement Offers
An adjuster will often contact you within hours or days of your crash with a quick cash offer. This offer sounds generous when you’re dealing with medical bills and lost wages.
However, these initial offers are often much lower than the true value of your claim. The adjuster makes this offer before you know the full extent of your injuries or understand your future medical needs.
Once you accept and sign the release for Missouri car accident settlements, you give up your right to any additional compensation. Even if your injuries worsen or you discover new problems, you cannot go back for more money.
Recorded Statements
The other driver’s insurer will often ask to record you early, before you’ve seen all your doctors or had time to process what happened. They frame it as paperwork. It’s not. It’s a chance to lock you into answers they can use later.
You have no legal duty to give a recorded statement to the at-fault insurer in Missouri. Adjusters ask leading questions—”You were going pretty fast, right?” —to make it sound like you share the blame or aren’t badly hurt. The safest move is to decline and send them to us.
If your own insurer needs a statement under your policy, we’ll prepare you and be on the call to keep it fair and limited.
Medical Authorizations
Insurance companies often send blanket medical authorization forms, claiming these will speed up your claim processing. The form looks official and reasonable on the surface.
Signing this authorization gives them access to your entire medical history going back years. They will search for any pre-existing conditions, old injuries, or past treatments.
If you had back pain five years ago, they’ll argue that’s the real cause of your current back injury, not the motorcycle crash. This tactic helps them deny or reduce your claim.
Blame and Comparative Fault
Missouri uses comparative fault: your recovery drops by your share of blame. If you’re tagged with 27%, you collect 73%. Insurers know this and try to stick you with a slice of fault—even when the facts don’t support it.
Typical angles include:
- “You were speeding,” even if you were at the limit.
- “You were lane-splitting,” whether or not it happened.
- “You weren’t wearing proper gear” to downplay injuries.
- “You were riding recklessly,” based on bias against riders.
Don’t debate these points on your own. Keep it brief and send the adjuster to us. We push back with evidence, not assumptions.
Delay Tactics and Red Tape
One of the oldest plays is stalling. The longer the claim drags on, the more pressure you feel from medical bills and lost income—and the cheaper your case looks to them.
Delays show up the same way again and again: “We need more documents,” silence for weeks, repeat requests for records you already sent, mail “lost” or sent to the wrong address, and new adjusters who “need time to get up to speed.”
The point is simple—wear you down until a low offer sounds acceptable. Don’t let delay set the value of your claim.
Misuse of Medical Records
Insurance adjusters without medical training will review your treatment records and second-guess your doctors. They look for any reason to dispute your medical care or minimize your injuries.
If there’s a gap in your treatment, they’ll claim you must have recovered, even if you couldn’t afford to continue seeing doctors. They frequently argue that necessary procedures are “excessive” or “unrelated” to the accident.
They might also claim that your injuries should have healed by now, regardless of what your doctor says about your recovery timeline.
Surveillance and Social Media Checks
Insurers sometimes hire investigators to film you in public, looking for moments they can spin. A few seconds of you carrying a bag can become “no back injury.” They’ll also comb your social media; a smile at a birthday party can be used to suggest you’re fine.
Protect yourself: pause posting, lock down privacy settings, don’t accept new requests, and ask friends not to tag you. Assume you’re on camera any time you’re out—and tell us if you notice surveillance so we can address it.
Coverage Limits Misrepresentation
An adjuster might tell you there’s only a small amount of insurance coverage available, like the state minimum of $25,000. This creates pressure to settle quickly for whatever is “available.”
They often fail to mention additional policies that might apply, such as coverage in commercial truck accidents if the driver was working, or umbrella policies that provide extra protection. While Missouri law requires insurers to disclose policy limits when asked, they don’t volunteer this information.
Additional Tactics To Be Aware Of
Frequently, the insurance company will use additional underhanded tactics if you do not have proper representation, including:
- Withholding payment for a rental car even if the other driver is at fault and your motorcycle has been damaged to the extent that it is no longer driveable.
- Offering to reimburse you for your damaged or totaled motorcycle at a value less than what it was worth.
- Denial of full or partial responsibility for the crash.
- “Foot-dragging” in verifying insurance coverage.
- Denial of all or some of your bills related to the accident.
- Denial of bills related to the type of medical care you sought and needed for your injuries, such as specialty medical care, chiropractic treatment, and/or physical, occupational, or speech rehabilitation.
- Denial of lost wages for the time you had to take off work while recovering. This includes compensation for disability payments as well as vacation and personal days, even if your employer paid for these during your absence.
- Refusal to include provision for ongoing or additional medical and/or rehabilitative treatment should you need it or if further complications related to your injury, such as osteoarthritis, are likely to Such treatment may extend for years or even a lifetime but should be included if medically predicted.
- Denial of your injuries because you did not seek immediate medical attention or there were noticeable gaps of time from one doctor visit to the next over the course of treatment.
- Refusal to acknowledge your injuries as “acute” or having been caused by the crash.
- “Foot-dragging” in spite of knowing that your medical bills are mounting.
- Treatment that is intimidating, disrespectful, untruthful, apathetic—could care less about the consequences for you—and unprofessional, such as refusal to answer calls.
Why Insurance Companies Shift Blame
Missouri follows a pure comparative fault system. This means you can still recover compensation even if you’re found partially at fault for the accident. If you’re partly responsible, your compensation will be reduced according to your percentage of liability.
Insurance companies understand this system and use it to their advantage. By assigning you even a small percentage of fault, they can significantly reduce what they have to pay.
Here’s how fault percentages affect your compensation:
| Your Fault Percentage | Award Amount | You Receive |
| 0% | $100,000 | $100,000 |
| 20% | $100,000 | $80,000 |
| 40% | $100,000 | $60,000 |
| 60% | $100,000 | $40,000 |
This is why proving the other driver’s complete fault is so important to your financial recovery.
The Danger of Not Having Legal Representation
Unless you are highly skilled in Missouri personal injury law, trying to match your negotiating skills against those of the insurance company will surely be intimidating for you.
The insurance company negotiates settlements in personal injury cases every day. They make their living doing so. The average person is not trained to properly evaluate their own motorcycle accident case.
They will have no experience comparing the value of the case with actual jury verdicts or settlements in other similar motorcycle accident cases.
In our experience, motorcycle accidents often have large damages because being in this type of accident usually results in much more severe injuries.
In addition, some riders say they never want to ride again, and some say they get scared every time they get on their bike. This can be considered a form of post-traumatic stress, which is a very serious repercussion of the accident that cannot be overlooked.
Our experienced St. Louis personal injury attorneys can place a true value on your case. To do this, the attorney will take into account not only the total amount of your medical bills and lost wages, but also what damages you have suffered and will be suffering in the future.
All damages require evidence. Usually, injuries are documented through medical records from the treating medical provider. Each time you have a doctor’s visit or therapy session, the doctor or therapist will document the original problems and the progress being made in treating the injuries.
How To Avoid Being Taken Advantage Of
Strong evidence is your best defense against insurance company tactics. At Beck & Beck Missouri Car Accident Lawyers, we’ve helped riders recover millions by knowing what evidence matters and how to preserve it.
The key is acting quickly before critical evidence disappears or gets destroyed.
See a Doctor and Follow Orders
Get checked right away—ER, urgent care, or your doctor—even if you feel okay. Adrenaline can hide injuries for hours or days. Following the treatment plan creates a clear record tying your injuries to the crash; gaps in care let insurers argue you weren’t really hurt.
Save everything: visit summaries, follow-up instructions, prescriptions, and receipts. Show up, follow through, and document it. It protects your health and your claim.
Save Your Gear Helmet and Bike
Don’t toss or repair anything. Your cracked helmet, torn jacket, scuffed boots, and damaged motorcycle parts are physical evidence. A fractured shell shows the force of impact, and damage patterns on the bike help experts reconstruct how the crash happened.
Keep everything in its original condition. Store the items in a dry, secure place, bag and label loose parts, and take clear photos. Hold onto receipts. If the insurer wants an inspection, send them to us—we’ll coordinate it so the evidence is preserved and properly documented.
Preserve Video GPS and EDR Data
Your motorcycle may store pre-crash data—speed, braking, throttle—in an event data recorder (EDR). Paired with video and location data, it can make liability clear.
Act fast. Security footage from nearby businesses or homes, traffic cameras, and dashcams is often overwritten within days. GPS data from your phone or navigation app can show your route and speed, and cell-phone records can rebut “distracted riding” claims.
Bring devices to us before they’re reset, repaired, or replaced. Don’t hand them to the other insurer. We’ll send preservation letters, coordinate downloads, and secure the raw files so critical evidence isn’t lost.
Avoid Recorded Statements and Blanket Releases
You have no duty to give a recorded statement to the at-fault insurer in Missouri. Keep it simple: “I need to speak with my lawyer before giving any formal statement.”
Don’t sign blanket medical authorizations. Those forms open your entire history, not just crash-related care, and insurers use that to downplay your injuries. We’ll provide only the records that matter and limit the dates and providers.
If you must communicate, do it in writing and keep it brief. Save copies. Better yet, direct all calls and emails to us so there’s a clean record and no surprises.
Keep a Symptom and Impact Journal
Keep a daily log: pain level (0–10), where it hurts, sleep, meds and side effects, and tasks you couldn’t do. Add specifics—missed work, skipped activities with your kids, needing help to dress. Date every entry, include good and bad days, and add photos if helpful. This helps your doctors and proves how the injuries affect your life.
How We Counter Insurance Tactics for Missouri Motorcyclists
At Beck & Beck Missouri Car Accident Lawyers, we focus exclusively on auto-accident cases in Missouri. That focus matters. We know the insurer’s playbook, and we move before adjusters do—building leverage early and keeping it through trial if that’s what your case requires.
From day one, we secure evidence, control the record, and take the pressure off you. We handle the claim so you can handle your recovery.
- Immediate investigation: Rapid preservation of scene evidence, photos/videos, EDR/GPS data, and witness statements.
- Accident reconstruction: Specialists analyze crash dynamics to pinpoint causation and liability.
- Medical support: We connect you with experts who treat motorbike injuries and do not ask for an upfront payment.
- Trial-ready negotiation: We build every case as if a jury will see it, which forces fairer settlement talks.
- Total insurer contact: We take over all calls, emails, and forms to stop adjuster tactics and protect your claim.
Insurers know we won’t chase lowball offers. When the other side understands we’re prepared to try the case, the conversation changes—and so do the numbers.
Skilled Missouri Motorcycle Accident Law Firm
Dealing with motorcycle accident injuries is hard enough without fighting an insurance company that’s working against you. You’re probably facing significant medical bills, lost wages, and uncertainty about your future.
Reach out anytime for a free consultation. There’s no obligation. You won’t owe attorney fees unless we win, and we advance the costs of investigators, experts, and court filings so you’re not paying out of pocket.
When you contact us, we move fast to protect your claim:
- Stop the calls: All insurer communication goes through us.
- Preserve evidence: We secure video, records, and data before they’re lost.
- Meet deadlines: We handle filings and court requirements.
- Build leverage: We start the case strategy right away.
The clock is already running. Let us preserve evidence and push back. Contact Beck & Beck Missouri Car Accident Lawyers for a free case review.
Cities in Missouri where our skilled attorneys have assisted motorcycle riders with their injury claims include St. Louis, Jefferson City, Independence, O’Fallon, Florissant, Springfield, Columbia, and more.
Related Articles
Can I recover compensation for a motorcycle accident if I wasn’t wearing a helmet?
What to do immediately following a motorcycle accident in Missouri
